Product Liability vs Criminal Liability vs Consumer Compensation

⚖️ Product Liability vs Criminal Liability vs Consumer Compensation (Product Fraud)

Feature / Basis Product Liability Criminal Liability (IPC / BNS) Consumer Compensation (CPA, 2019)
Definition Manufacturer / seller की जिम्मेदारी कि product safe, standard और defect-free हो अपराध / धोखाधड़ी करने पर राज्य द्वारा दंड उपभोक्ता को नुकसान या fraud के लिए मुआवज़ा देना
Legal Basis Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – Section 2(34), 83–87 IPC Sections 415, 420, 463, 468, 489 / BNS Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – Sections 2(10), 2(28), 2(34), 84–87
Nature Civil liability / strict liability Criminal liability Civil remedy / compensation
Intent Required (Mens Rea) No – Liability बनती है चाहे intention हो या नहीं Yes – धोखाधड़ी / cheating / intentional misrepresentation No – सिर्फ नुकसान होना जरूरी
Who is Liable? Manufacturer, Seller, Service Provider Fraudster / Seller / Manufacturer / Distributor Seller / Manufacturer / Online Platform
Examples Defective electronic, expired medicine, mislabeled food Fake product sold knowingly, counterfeit, adulterated product Refund, replacement, compensation for damage / loss
Penalty / Outcome Replacement / Repair / Refund / Product recall Jail (up to 7 years) + Fine Monetary compensation to consumer + sometimes court-ordered apology
Applicable Laws Consumer Protection Act, 2019; Legal Metrology Act, 2009; FSSAI IPC / BNS; Drugs & Cosmetics Act, 1940; Legal Metrology Act, 2009 Consumer Protection Act, 2019
Scope All defective, unsafe, misleading products Intentional fraud / criminal misconduct All harmed consumers, including online & offline
Timeframe for Action Immediate liability once product is defective Court / police investigation (variable) Complaint resolution 60–90 days in Consumer Court; 5–7 days online grievance (fast track)
Online Applicability Yes – E-commerce Rules, 2020 Yes – IPC applies to online fraud Yes – CPA + E-commerce grievance mechanism
Objective / Purpose Protect consumer from unsafe / defective products Punish intentional fraudsters / protect society Compensate consumer for loss or injury due to defective / fraudulent product